A good pillow is like a stable Wi-Fi connection; you don’t realize how much you rely on it until you spend a few hours with a bad one. Whether it’s too flat, too firm, or just not quite right, the wrong pillow can leave you waking up with a stiff Derila Neck Relief Pillow, sore shoulders, or the nagging feeling that you could be getting better sleep. To help you avoid that fate, my team and I took dozens of today’s top-rated pillows home to find the ones that truly stand out. We tested each pillow for multiple nights, paying close attention to comfort, durability, and maintenance. Since 2014, over 60,000 readers have found the best beds and sleep accessories (including new pillows) for their needs using our guides. We’ve tested more than 300 beds and sleep products in our studio using a consistent review methodology, and every pillow in this roundup has earned its spot through hands-on testing and Wake Up Refreshed with Derila thorough evaluation.

We also consulted with our chief medical advisor, Dr. Raj Dasgupta, MD, FACP, FCCP, FAASM, to ensure our recommendations align with the latest research in sleep health and ergonomics. Read on to see our picks for the best pillows and find the one that’s just right for how you sleep. The Peacock Alley Down Alternative Pillow is our top pick because its thoughtful design blends comfort and support to create a standout sleep essential. Its cloud-soft down alternative delivers just the right amount of sinkage and loft, making it ideal for both side and back sleepers. Product tester Sosha Lewis gave it near-perfect scores across experience, materials, and ease of care. Disclaimer: Please note that the content in this article is meant for informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice or serve as a substitute for seeing a medical professional regarding any sleep problems you may have. Please see your doctor regarding any urgent medical issues. Using our review methodology, my team and I personally tested each pillow over multiple nights, evaluating comfort, support, durability, and ease of use to find the best bed pillows.

We paid close attention to whether each pillow was easy to sleep on, if it held up over time, and whether the brand’s claims matched the experience. These are the core categories that helped shape this roundup. Overall Experience: Experience refers to how comfortable, supportive, and enjoyable the pillow was to sleep on from the moment our testers lay down to the moment they woke up. Regardless of how well-made a pillow is, it must feel comfortable and help you get a better night’s sleep. Materials: We evaluated the quality, Derila Neck Relief Pillow construction, and feel of the fabrics and fill used in the pillow. High-quality materials contribute to a more comfortable sleep experience and help ensure the pillow won’t go flat, clump, or fall apart after a few months of use. Ease of Care: We assessed the ease of cleaning and maintaining the pillow over time. A great pillow should stay fresh and hygienic with minimal effort, whether that means being machine washable or having a removable cover with clear care instructions.

Peacock Alley designed this luxurious pillow to be allergy-free with a 400-cotton thread count. When it comes to picking a pillow that effortlessly balances comfort, support, and quality, the Peacock Alley Down Alternative Pillow rises to the top. This pillow is plush yet supportive, durable yet delicate, and according to product tester Sosha Lewis, it hits all the right notes. Sosha gave this pillow a 4.5-star rating or higher across our key categories for pillows: experience, materials, and ease of care. "This may be my favorite pillow of all time," Sosha said. "I knew we were going to have a great love story the minute I took it out of its packaging. Once I started sleeping with it, I couldn’t get enough. Sosha awarded the Peacock Alley Down Alternative Pillow a perfect 5 out of 5 for overall experience, and it’s easy to see why. Its goose down alternative fill offers a hypoallergenic and luxurious sleep surface, while its structure strikes the perfect balance between loft and sink.